Silver City Sarasota

Nicole Tanksley

3 months ago

I am down here on vacation and my silver chain broke and Silver City Sarasota not only came in clutch with a beautiful chain to replace the broken one cause it was not fixable but polished my St. Florian pendant and my turtle and made them shine. Absolutely love the chain and it was reasonably priced. Service was amazing and the ladies were super friendly. Will definitely be ordering from them for future jewelry ♥️

Maripili Diaz

2 months ago

I come to this shop every time I am in Siesta Key. I buy my yearly silver city piece! Debra, Suzanne, Monica, and Tris always display such patience and honesty as I try on EVERYTHING! Their pieces are great quality and timeless as well. They even pack everything with cleaning bags and polish rags. Great service, great items, and you can support an important small business presence on the island.

Wendy achtel

3 months ago

I'm so glad I found Silver City! They took a broken silver tennis bracelet & made a beautiful necklace & earrings with it. It's absolutely gorgeous!!! I've gotten so many compliments on it. The jeweler did such a wonderful job on this custom made set! I'll definitely be back - the pieces in the display cases are just gorgeous!

Debbie Conradt

4 months ago

Can not say enough great things about the ladies in this shop! Suzanne was very helpful with the Siesta Key Watercolor Gemstone collection. So many beautiful pieces. I was able to pick out a bracelet, earrings and a ring. The attention to customer service was beyond memorable! Thank you for the lovely experience. Hope to make it back into your store again. Debbie 11-21-25

Ivory Stokes

a month ago

This is a wonderful jewelry shop. Graciela and the ladies that work here are so kind and ready to help without feeling like they're being pushy at all. Their Siesta Key gemstone is beautiful, and their prices are decent too

Susanna Klein

4 months ago

My trips to Sarasota are never complete without a visit to Silver City Sarasota. It’s the place to go for beautiful silver jewelry and the Siesta Key Gemstone collection is just stunning. So many unique pieces to choose from and everything is quality. Monica, Suzanne and Debra are wonderful and so helpful. Never pushy. I’ve never been disappointed with anything I’ve purchased there.

Barb Voris

2 months ago

LOVE visiting this beautiful shop when I am in town! Bought a bracelet last time and a beautiful pair of silver earrings this time! (I walked in and they were calling my name! Love them!) Suzanne was so sweet and did an amazing job at explaining the difference pieces. Thank you! I will be back next year!

Cyann Rodriguez

6 months ago

I was truly blessed of finding this place while staying in Sarasota if you are silver jewelry lover like I am this is THE PLACE!! Such amazing sweet ladies you will have no doubt a great experience there Suzanne was such a sweetheart took care of me while shopping around there on my birthday such amazing quality lovely pieces in there so many to browse from they make you feel welcomed I cannot wait to be back please visit here if you are in the area you will not regret it! Such an amazing loving energy this store has. I love all my pieces I got there.

Amy Mantooth

7 months ago

When l first saw the Siesta Key Watercolor gemstones l knew l had to have one. With the help of Monica, I chose the perfect bracelet for me. The colors in the Siesta Key Watercolor Gemstone are stunning and actually the photo of my bracelet doesn’t do it justice. I loved it so much that l purchased a pair of Watercolor Gemstone earrings to go with it. I highly recommend Silver City Sarasota for not only this beautiful Siesta Key Watercolor Gemstone that is exclusive to them but their selection of other beautiful jewelry and best of all the Staff are amazing!! I will be purchasing from them again!

Alexa P

2 months ago

This is an amazing place for high quality silver jewelry! Both of my silver rings are from here and have lasted me for years. Friendly service & fairly priced, I highly recommend silver city if you are looking for a silver piece in Sarasota :)